The Mortgage Rate Tipping Point: When 5% Becomes the Magic Number for Homeowners

The Mortgage Rate Tipping Point: When 5% Becomes the Magic Number for Homeowners

  • Faber Real Estate Tem
  • 10/18/23

The Mortgage Rate Tipping Point: When 5% Becomes the Magic Number for Homeowners

The recent hike in mortgage rates has given rise to what economists and real estate experts are referring to as the 'golden handcuff' effect. A striking 82% of homeowners reportedly feel “locked-in” by their existing low-rate mortgages, as per data from In today's climate, where the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate has escalated above 7%, many homeowners find the idea of selling their homes unappealing. However, recent studies indicate that there is a 'tipping point,' a mortgage rate at which homeowners are willing to make a move. That magic number appears to be around 5% to 5.5%. In this blog post, we'll delve into this phenomenon and its ramifications for the housing market.

The Golden Handcuff Effect: A Brief Overview

Similar to retention bonuses in the corporate world designed to keep employees from leaving, the ‘golden handcuff’ effect in the real estate sector refers to homeowners who are deterred from selling their homes due to their current low mortgage rates. This feeling of being “locked in” is accentuated by the realization that moving would mean refinancing at a much higher rate, thereby significantly increasing monthly mortgage payments.

Nicole Bachaud, a senior economist at Zillow, notes that "Even if they bought a cheaper house, their payments would go up." Essentially, many homeowners find themselves in a catch-22: they either can't afford to or are unwilling to finance a new home at current market rates.

The Tipping Point: The Magic of 5%

According to a survey by John Burns Research and Consulting, 71% of potential homebuyers planning to finance their next home purchase with a mortgage stated they wouldn't accept a rate above 5.5%. A parallel study by Zillow found that existing homeowners are almost twice as likely to sell their home if their mortgage rate is 5% or higher.

Bob Wood, a finance professor who is contemplating selling his home in Mobile, Alabama, voices a sentiment shared by many: "We are in the 10th year of a 3.125% 15-year fixed mortgage. We just don’t want to pay that much in interest." Wood adds that he would be more inclined to move if the rates come down to "the 4%-5% range."

The Impact on Home Supply and Prices

The reluctance to sell at current rates has led to a scarcity in housing listings, which are approximately 20% behind last year's pace. This shortage is exacerbating the upward pressure on home prices, making it an even more challenging environment for buyers.

Greg McBride, Bankrate’s chief financial analyst, states, “The reality of it is, until inflation comes down in a meaningful and sustainable way, mortgage rates are going to stay high.”

What Lies Ahead?

While mortgage rates might not go back to sub-3% levels in the near future, experts like Jacob Channel, senior economist at LendingTree, believe there's no reason to assume that they will remain as high as they currently are forever. The housing market has shown resilience in the past and there is optimism that it will rebound again.

Until Then

The rise in mortgage rates has created a somewhat stagnant market where homeowners are reluctant to move due to their existing low-rate mortgages. However, as data suggests, a 5% mortgage rate could serve as the tipping point that activates the market once again. Until then, the 'golden handcuff' effect continues to dominate, creating a unique set of challenges and opportunities for both buyers and sellers in the real estate landscape.

While the industry navigates these turbulent waters, it remains essential for both buyers and sellers to stay informed and carefully consider their options. If you find yourself on either side of this equation, a strategic approach tailored to the current market conditions is indispensable.

Connect with Us: Faber Real Estate Team

Navigating the current real estate market with its fluctuating mortgage rates can be a complex task. Whether you're contemplating selling your home or in the market to buy, having an experienced team to guide you can make all the difference. That's where we come in.

The Faber Real Estate Team is dedicated to providing you with top-notch service tailored to your individual needs. Based in Marin County, we have the local expertise and in-depth market knowledge to help you make informed decisions. Our team can offer personalized consultations to help you understand how the current mortgage rate trends may affect your buying or selling plans.

Why Choose Faber Real Estate Team?

  • Expert advice on navigating the 'golden handcuff' effect
  • Up-to-date market analytics and trends
  • Personalized home evaluation
  • Customized buying or selling strategies
  • Local expertise in Marin County

Don't let the uncertainty of the market hold you back. Reach out to us today for a consultation and let us help you take your next steps with confidence.

The Key To Your Dreams ®

As your trusted real estate advisors, we are committed to delivering the highest level of service and marketing, sharing our experience and expertise to help you achieve exceptional results.

Follow Us